Peer Review Feedback Forms

research paper presentations:

  • Presenter name: Tamerlan Tserenov
  • Topic: nostalgia and its impact 
  • Thesis: how does nostalgia impact our lives including memories, emotions and comfort. 
  • Question: how does nostalgia affects our mood?
  • Glow: good use of slides, not a lot of writing and helpful visuals.
  • Grow: read too much off the phone. 
  • Presenter name: Gabriella Chang
  • Topic: minimally invasive Heart vs Open Heart surgery
  • Thesis: which approach is better to operate on the heart, open heart surgery or minimally invasive surgery.
  • Question: what is the name of the heart and lung machine that takes over their function?
  • Glow: the explanations were very thorough and easily broken down even though there were complex terms. 
  • Grow: I actually don’t think I have a grow.
  • Presenter name: Kevin Ortiz 
  • Topic: The biological basis of Sexual orientation
  • Thesis: orientation is not a voluntary choice regarding sexuality
  • Question: Are the genes that prove sexual orientation is biological considered mutations or abnormal?
  • Glow:  Good use of statistics, they show positive results and further prove your ideas!!!.
  • Grow: slides are pretty but the use of light colors made me a little blind.
  • Presenter name: Ryan
  • Topic: therapeutic cloning and its limitations
  • Thesis: how do stem cells contribute to therapeutic cloning
  • Question: how would you define cloning?
  • Glow: like how you brought up what society thinks rather than just scholars specialized in the topic
  • Grow: read too much from phone
  • Presenter name: cidney
  • Topic: immortal jellyfish 
  • Thesis: jellyfish abilities and biological aspects can help mankind reach immortality 
  • Question: is it genetically proven?
  • Glow: good idea of a topic
  • Grow: too little slides 
  • Presenter name: Jayvalyn Fernandez
  • Topic: era of designer babies: potential impacts of selecting physical and intellectual traits in offsprings.
  • Thesis: can designer babies change traits in offsprings and impact society for the better.
  • Question: how would you edit the DNA to match the intellect you may want? 
  • Glow: interesting topic, well explained
  • Grow: made little to no eye contact with the audience and had a lot of writing on the slides, almost no visual content.

PEER REVIEW (justin).docx